Making an easy, nutritious dinner is easy with this vegetarian unstuffed pepper casserole recipe! Strips of bell pepper are cooked alongside the deliciously spiced tomato lentil sauce to bring you the flavors and textures you love from a vegetarian stuffed pepper – but in a faster and easier casserole form!
Stuffed peppers are a vegetarian staple, and the format is adaptable and lends itself to so many cuisines and fillings. There is a stuffed pepper for everyone. Even, it turns out, those who would prefer a casserole.
Enter the “unstuffed peppers” or the stuffed pepper casserole, or the deconstructed stuffed pepper? Whatever you’d like to call it.
I’ve seen this idea floating around a lot on social media but it usually calls for ground meat. This meatless version uses… surprise surprise! Lentils. As regular readers will know, lentils are just my fave thing to stand in for ground meat. So healthy, so versatile, so cheap, so perfect.
Some finely chopped mushrooms float around in there for added “meaty”ness and it all comes together in a tomato sauce.
Now while I love using lentils to make things vegetarian, it can turn out pretty dull if we don’t flavor it right. You see that bowl of spices right in the middle? That’s how we make it fly. We have things like smoked paprika, fennel seeds, allspice… just to give it a really warm, tasty finish.
The mix of spices used don’t fit into a particular genre, and none of them are too dominant or overbearing. Together they leave this casserole tasting great but still simple.
Oh, that cheese. A big layer of mozzarella finishes this off perfectly and adds that a little bit of textural difference that helps keep a casserole interesting.
How to make it
There’s a printable recipe card coming right up, but just a quick visual of how this all comes together. You’re just sautéing things in a pan, then topping with cheese and baking. Easy stuff here.
And the grand finale… that beautiful moment where you cut into the cheese for the first time.
Adjustments and Substitutions
I’ve used green lentils here but brown, puy or black lentils would all swap in fine. I call for 1.5 cups of cooked lentils (which will be 1/2 cup dried, if you’re cooking them especially) but you can also swap in a can of lentils no problem. A can would be a tiny bit less, but it’s not a problem. I suggest making lentils in an instant pot if you have one!
Add beans! A can of white beans would be fantastic here and elevate this to a high protein situation.
This casserole is very adaptable to what is in your fridge. Extra veggies always welcome. Just be mindful of when you add them. Hard veggies with low moisture can go in with the onions and peppers. But anything that leaches moisture (zucchini, something frozen, a watery squash) should go in with the mushrooms once the peppers are cooked to your liking.
I call for two cans of tomatoes here, and I use plain ol’ chopped tomatoes but you can use whole (just break them up a little with the wooden spoon). It would also be delicious to swap in cans of fire roasted tomatoes or cherry tomatoes if you can get them, just to bump up the yum factor a little more.
I highly recommend bagged shredded mozzarella for this recipe. The coating they put on the cheese to stop it sticking together in the bag is quite helpful. It keeps the cheese dry enough to make a delicious distinct topping in a short space of time without any sinking in and getting lost (which is what happened when I used cheddar that I grated off a block).
OK, ready to roll? Go forth and unstuff some peppers.
Vegetarian Stuffed Pepper Casserole
- 3 bell peppers, all red or mixed colors, whatever you prefer, sliced
- 1 red onion, minced
- 6 garlic cloves, crushed
- 7 oz (200 g) mushrooms, chopped into small pieces
- 2 Tbsp butter
- 1.5 cups (1.5 cups) cooked green or brown lentils*
- 28 oz (800 g) canned tomatoes
- 2 cups (250 g) shredded mozzarella
- 1 Tbsp cumin
- 1 Tbsp smoked paprika
- 2 tsp fennel seeds
- 1 tsp chili powder
- 1 tsp allspice
- ¼ tsp cinnamon
- First, measure out your spices and combine them in a small bowl. Set aside.
- In a large oven-proof casserole dish, heat a glug of olive oil and saute your onions and pepper strips. You want to get to the point where the peppers are softening and starting to blister but still holding their shape – see the photos in the blog post for clarity. (You can cook them longer if you’d prefer them to be extra soft and melty in the casserole.)
- Add the mushrooms and garlic and cook until the mushrooms have reduced and the garlic is smelling lovely.
- Turn down the heat and then add the spice mix and butter. The butter will melt and toast the spices a little. Be careful not to let it burn. If everything seems dry, add more butter or pour in a little extra olive oil. You want it to have a rich, caramelized feel.
- Add the lentils and then mix them into until they’re nicely coated with the spices too.
- Add the canned tomatoes and simmer the mixture for about 10 to minutes while you preheat the oven to 200C / 400F.
- Once the oven is heated, scatter the shredded mozzarella on top of the casserole and bake for 20 minutes or until the mozzarella is browned and the casserole is bubbling. (In the meantime you can prepare some rice or potatoes to serve alongside.)
- Let rest for 5 minutes before serving.
I made this last night and it was delicious! I added squash when I did the mushrooms (as recommended in the write up). I didn’t have any all spice but I felt it was plenty flavorful. I used my Dutch oven and it worked out perfectly. Mozzarella was nice and bubbly! I love using recipes with lentils to give my 8 month old an extra iron boost!
Fantastic, I am so happy to hear this turned out well for you Missy, thank you for sharing your feedback! It is definitely a great idea to get your little one into lentils, they are such a perfect food. And yay for bubbly mozzarella.
I made a few adjustments to this recipe – added a little salt and lots of black pepper, a sprinkling of chilli flakes, a square of dark chocolate for richness and a teaspoon of sugar to balance the tomatoes.
Nice recipe and lots left over which I’ll put into tortilla wraps, cover with cheese sauce and bake in the oven.
Love having an (almost) ready-made meal for next day!
Great ideas! Sounds amazing! 🙂
This is so delicious. Have made it twice – veggie 20 month old and carnivore husband both adore it. Have shared with other toddler mums because it’s a great one for all the family to enjoy. Thank you!
I am so happy to hear this, thank you for taking the time to feed back, really makes my day! 🙂
Sounds wonderful! Going to try today on this cold, blustery day in Pittsburgh! Out of lentils, Will quinoa work as well?
Quinoa should work! Let me know how it turns out 🙂
This recipe looks great. Just wondering if you drain the tomatoes before adding or if they are added with their juices.
With their juices! Hope you enjoy 🙂